Robert Barrett & Ors v Robert Morgan (2000)

Judgment Date: 27 Jan 00

Summary A notice to quit served by a landlord by pre-arrangement with the headtenant, and on the common understanding or agreement that the headtenant would not serve a counternotice, was effective at common law to determine both the headtenancy and any subtenancy held under it, and was not tantamount to...

Secretary of State for Trade & Industry v Colin Robert Dyer & Ors (2000)

Judgment Date: 24 Jan 00

Summary Where in disqualification proceedings under the Company Directors' Disqualification Act 1986 the question arose as to whether a company was operating a policy of non-payment of Crown debts the court should consider the treatment of other creditors and in the absence of cross-examination should accept the respondent's explanation where this...

Trustees of Gunter Estate v Tristem

Judgment Date: 12 Jan 00

Summary Despite an inapt clause in a lease which suggested, when read alone, that a tenant was not liable for contributing towards the maintenance charges for those common parts of a building which she was not entitled to use, the overall intention of the parties was clearly that the tenant...

Nightingale Mayfair Ltd v Mehta (1999)

Judgment Date: 21 Dec 99

Summary A debtor who caused a property purchased with his money to be transferred into a trust or settlement for the purposes of a tax avoidance scheme had successfully deprived himself of any beneficial interest in the property. Futhermore, a promissory note constituted "valuable consideration" for the purposes of s.23(1)...

Barclays Bank PLC v Coleman & Anor (1999)

Judgment Date: 21 Dec 99

Summary A new trial was refused to a defendant who had been refused an adjournment and had had to conduct his case in person. Where a wife sought to set aside a mortgage on the grounds of undue influence, the issues were: (i) the meaning of "manifest disadvantage"; and (ii)...

Ashworth Frazer Ltd v Gloucester City Council (1999)

Judgment Date: 21 Dec 99

Summary This was an appeal from the decision of David Donaldson QC sitting as a Deputy Judge of the Chancery Division between the appellant, and its landlord, Gloucester City Council . Facts appeal raised two questions: (i) Whether (a), as the council contended, the covenant in cl.2(iii)(a) "to complete...

David Gareth Jones v Society of Lloyd’s : Mervyn John Anthony Standen v Same (1999)

Judgment Date: 16 Dec 99

Summary Whether provision in the Lloyd's settlement agreement that underwriting members who did not pay their reduced liabilities in full by a certain date would be liable for their full liabilities was in the nature of an unenforceable penalty or constituted a provision for forfeiture. Facts These were two sets...

Houghton & Ors v (1) Clive Fayers (2) Howard Day (1999)

Judgment Date: 09 Dec 99

Summary Unconditional leave was granted to defend a claim for knowing receipt of sums subject to a constructive trust and/or knowing assistance in respect of the disposal of such sums, as the evidence was insufficient to support a summary decision. Facts Interlocutory appeal by the second defendant ('D') against...

Houghton & Ors v (1) Clive Fayers (2) Howard Day (1999)

Judgment Date: 09 Dec 99

Summary Unconditional leave was granted to defend a claim for knowing receipt of sums subject to a constructive trust and/or knowing assistance in respect of the disposal of such sums, as the evidence was insufficient to support a summary decision. Facts Interlocutory appeal by the second defendant ('D') against...