Ashworth Frazer Ltd v Gloucester City Council

Judgment Date: 08 Nov 01

Summary A covenant in a lease by which the lessee agreed to erect a building development fit for uses within certain specified classes of the Town and Country (Use Classes) Order 1963 did not mean that the demised land could only be used for those purposes. A landlord would rarely be...

Mobil Oil Co Ltd v Birmingham City Council (2001)

Judgment Date: 02 Nov 01

Summary Rent Review. Whether tenant's adjoining freehold premises had implied easement over leasehold land or whether leasehold land had special value for providing access. Facts Appeal by the claimant ('M') from the decision of Kevin Garnett QC by which he dismissed M's claim for a declaration that it was entitled...

UCB Group Ltd v Gillian Margaret Hedworth (2001)

Judgment Date: 02 Nov 01

Summary Application by the claimant ('UCB') for summary judgment under CPR Part 8 to vacate a caution registered in respect of a property for which the defendant ('D') claimed to be in receipt of the rents and profits within the meaning of s.70(1)(g) Land Registration Act 1925. D's husband ('H'), a...

Michael Bernand Worwood & Paul Edward Pike v Leisure Merchandising Services Ltd & 8 Ors (2001)

Judgment Date: 02 Nov 01

Summary The claimant shareholders had no real prospect of establishing that the defendant chargee had exercised its right to take possession of the shares for the collateral purpose of forcing the claimant's company out of business. Facts Claimants' appeal from part of a decision of Master Bowman by which he...

Banque Francaise De L’Orient v (1) Chesterbrook Financial Corporation (2) Hany Salaam (2001)

Judgment Date: 25 Oct 01

Summary The English courts had jurisdiction to hear claims arising from a contract made under French law but in which one party reserved the right to elect any other jurisdiction which was competent under the Brussels Convention 1968 and due to differences between French and English law the English courts were...

Jack Midwood v Anthony & Vanessa Morgan (2001)

Judgment Date: 25 Oct 01

Summary On its true construction, a right of pre-emption in favour of the defendants as "transferee" was exercisable only while they both remained beneficial owners of the property transferred to them. The right was lost by the execution of a deed of gift whereby one of the defendants disposed of...

Abbey National Plc v John Perry & Co (2001)

Judgment Date: 24 Oct 01

Summary An order allowing an amendment to statements of claim did not give rise to a new cause of action and was accordingly upheld. Facts Appeal from the order of Rimer J, sitting as the designated judge of the Abbey National Managed List, dated 14 February 2001, allowing Abbey National permission to...

Hart Investments PLC v Burton Hotels Ltd (2001)

Judgment Date: 23 Oct 01

Summary In a successful appeal from an order for possession, the trial judge had incorrectly construed an option to renew a lease as if it expressly provided that the deadline for service of the option notice was the expiry of the contractual term. Further, the trial judge should have allowed...

R v Trinity Development Co (Banbury) Ltd, Ex Parte National Car Parks Ltd (2001)

Judgment Date: 18 Oct 01

Summary An agreement to provide car parking facilities upon premises, taken as a whole, did not create a tenancy because exclusive possession was not granted under the agreement. Facts Appeal by National Car Parks Ltd ('NCP') from the decision of Judge Rich QC dismissing NCP's claim for a declaration that...